- 20190509: Minor Edits to formatting/weird numbers in wrong location.
The following write-up takes a look at the performance of Wooden Floor Spikes (Rare vs Legendary) in a way that is actually meaningful for players. As a result, it is going to be severely biased in certain respects. It is intentionally written this way (to keep things short). To do a proper breakdown on a material consumption/cost basis would be tedious to write, boring as hell and likely never truly relevant as far as general gameplay is concerned.
|Trap||Planks||Twine||Herbs||Adhesive Resin||Nuts & Bolts||Powder||Bacon|
|Wooden Floor Spikes (Rare)||6||2||3||1||–||–||–|
|Wooden Floor Spikes (Legendary)||8||2||6||2||–||–||–|
|Ceiling Gas Trap (Legendary)||–||–||7||–||11||2||1|
I'm going to deliberately put emphasis on the cost of herbs (whilst ignoring the rest of the materials). Fundamentally the more you 'gather' resources from around the map (regardless of how you do it) the more you'll be happy to consume, but if we assumed an infinite resource scenario then you'd always pick the legendary trap 100% of the time (defeating the point of looking at material costs in the first place).
- Legendary Wooden Floor Spikes cost double the herbs (of Rare)
I need to note that the base 'crit damage' bonus for a critical hit on wooden floor spikes is (per the UI) about +10% damage. Wooden Floor Spikes only have a base critical hit chance of 5% to begin with.
Excluding the Element: Physical perk slot
- You have 3 perks to work with for increasing damage (Rare)
- You have 4 perks to work with for increasing damage (Legendary)
- Rare traps could have: x3 damage perks, or swap out the damage for up to: x2 crit rating or x1 crit damage.
- Legendary traps could have : x4 damage perks, or swap out the damage for up to x2 crit rating or x2 crit damage.
- x1 crit rating perk = 33% critical hit chance
- x2 crit rating perks = 46% critical hit chance
- x1 crit damage perk = 145% crit damage bonus
- x2 crit damage perk = 280% crit damage bonus
The following example shows the math (no rounding applied) if you were to compare Rare vs Legendary Traps, at 4 star 40/40 with 3,000 tech, and assuming all perks were set to damage perks, where possible. The Legendary trap gets x1 additional 30% damage perk (compared to the Rare).
|Var||Type||Rare||Legendary||Rare (Numbers)||Legendary (Numbers)||Leg / Rare|
|A||BaseDamage + EvolutionDamage||15 * 1.6||18 * 1.6||24||28.8||1.2|
|B||1 + (SchematicLevel-1) * 0.05||1 + (40-1) * 0.05||1 + (40-1) * 0.05||2.95||2.95||1|
|C||1 + Tech/100 + SurvivorBonuses||1 + (3000/100) + 0||1 + (3000/100) + 0||31||31||1|
|D||1 + HeroBonuses + SchematicBonuses||1 + 0 + (0.44 + 0.3 + 0.3 + 0.3)||1 + 0 + (0.44 + 0.3 + 0.3 + 0.3 + 0.3)||2.34||2.64||1.128205128|
|E||Result = A * B * C * D||A * B * C * D||A * B * C * D||5135.832||6953.1264||1.353846154|
I'll come back and discuss these numbers later.
From a gameplay perspective, under normal conditions (no additional snares) any given wooden floor spike is likely to hit a husk twice (at best) before it walks off the tile. If we assume 2 hits from any given tile, then based on the crit chance.
5% Crit Chance
33% Crit Chance
46% Crit Chance
The following numbers mix/match the various perk combinations for the Rare Wooden Floor Spikes, assuming same conditions as earlier (3,000 tech, 4 star 40/40)
|Var||x3:Dmg, x0:cDmg, x0:cRating||x2:Dmg, x0:cDmg, x1:cRating||x1:Dmg, x1:cDmg, x1:cRating||x1:Dmg, x0:cDmg, x2:cRating||x0:Dmg, x1:cDmg, x2:cRating|
|x2 Hits||10271.664 (90.25%)||8954.784 (44.89%)||7637.904 (44.89%)||7637.904 (29.16%)||6321.024 (29.16%)|
|x1 Hit, x1 Crit||10785.2472 (09.50%)||9402.5232 (44.22%)||13175.3844 (44.22%)||8019.7992 (49.68%)||10903.7664 (49.68%)|
|x2 Crits||11298.8304 (00.25%)||9850.2624 (10.89%)||18712.8648 (10.89%)||8401.6944 (21.16%)||15486.5088 (21.16%)|
As mentioned earlier this is a biased write-up with emphasis on herbs. Keep that in mind.
When looking at the output of Rare vs Legendary traps, when all perks are set to %damage perks
- The legendary trap does ~ 35.38% more damage
- The legendary trap costs twice the amount of herbs.
- For +35.38% damage (per hit) you're paying +100% herbs.
Considering that 'herbs' are the most annoying to gather component of a wooden floor spike (in that you can't just go around pick-axing/punching terrain) and that you actually need to gather/open plants that seems like a really bad trade-off. You're doubling the herb cost to get slightly over a 1/3 extra damage per trap activation. Any herbs you spend on wooden floor spikes also means you cannot spend them on a gas trap.
- If you craft 7 Rare wooden floor spikes (instead of Legendary) you 'save' 21 herbs
- 21 herbs can be used to make x3 legendary gas traps (7 herbs per trap)
The primary purpose of using wooden floor spikes to begin with is to get the benefit of the 30% snare/slow effect (which stacks with other snare/slow effects). Stacking snares against regular husks gives you values that roughly look like this
|Speed||Time Per Tile|
If you have more time to attack the target (and you do attack the target) then the actual damage per trap becomes a lot less important (since you can obtain damage from alternative sources, if you have the time to perform the attacks).
Under the assumption that people wouldn't find it worthwhile to use Legendary wooden floor spikes (due to the trade off between herbs vs damage) I listed various perk combinations you could achieve with the Rare versions, and the probability of the damage (on a 2 hit basis). There is no inherently 'right or wrong' way to perk your traps, it just depends on whether you're willing to take risks. You need to keep in mind that 'damage done' is cumulative (from all sources), that a husk dies once the health reaches zero and 'overkill' is simply wasted damage.
- If you're relying on a crit (and it doesn't happen) that might cost you in the sense that (the living husk) might then trigger another trap)
- If you're not relying on crit then you're guaranteed a minimum, reliable amount and you can calculate that (in the worst case scenario, a husk is guaranteed to die after x attacks).
Personally (how I play, how I gather materials and the rate at which I gain them) I can't justify using Legendary Wooden Floor Spikes. They cost twice as many herbs for about a 35% increase in reliable damage (it's different if you want to gamble with crits since you can pick up an extra crit damage perk, I haven't included that in this write-up, but you should be able to figure it out fairly easily).
Having x2 Mythic Leads and Full Legendary Survivors would give you ~ 3236 tech (you could get more if you had mythic survivors). 3,000 tech and 4 star 40/40 is a realistic reference point for a 'solo player' going around Twine Peaks.
People are very unlikely to use a single wooden floor spike (you'd generally place a few of them in a row, in the husks direction of travel) so having a two hit example is a little misleading (as far as cumulative crit damage is concerned) but I needed to establish a frame of reference. If you stack enough snares to trap a really tanky husk (like Smasher, Mini-Boss) on a single tile like this then you'd get a lot more value out of a non-pure damage build (the more 'hits' in total, the greater opportunity for the crit build to shine). It ultimately comes down to whether a husk lives long enough (and takes enough damage) for a pure damage build to lose out to the randomness of crits in cumulative damage.
Source: Original link
© Post "Wooden Floor Spikes: Rare vs Legendary, with math and stuff you should consider for perks and usage." for game Fortnite.
Top 10 Most Anticipated Video Games of 2020
2020 will have something to satisfy classic and modern gamers alike. To be eligible for the list, the game must be confirmed for 2020, or there should be good reason to expect its release in that year. Therefore, upcoming games with a mere announcement and no discernible release date will not be included.
Top 15 NEW Games of 2020 [FIRST HALF]
2020 has a ton to look forward to...in the video gaming world. Here are fifteen games we're looking forward to in the first half of 2020.