A while ago I was searching for info on the mechanism of the charge blade when I stumbled upon a reddit post from another subreddit that was asking for specific details of the functionality of the mechanism with some speculation attached to it. After some thought, I think I managed to find a reasonable explanation for it, but since that post was archived, I decided to make my own.
Disclaimer: This theory will address the fluctuation of the phial energy of the weapon between its various parts and not how the energy itself is gathered. This theory isn't 100% consistent, so I will mark the points that aren't fully covered with an asterisk and I will try to address them as good as possible at the end of the theory
So, as we know, there are 3 parts of the charge blade in which the energy can be retained, the blade, the phials, and the axe head/shield (which are respectively represented by the phial charge/blade charge system, the phial storage system, and the shield charge system). The way the energy is able to travel from a part of the weapon to another has an order, being the blade the first point of energy storage, the phials the second, and the axe head/shield the third, each part has no way of gathering energy if it doesn't come directly from its previous part (except for one exception that I will cover later on.
With these concepts in mind we can start explaining how the energy travels from one point of another.
-shield charge: We know that we are able to store the energy gathered from the blade inside the inner phials of the weapon, but how does the shield get charged at all, and why doesn't it get charged in the first place while loading phials? As we know, the shield is charged via canceling an amped elemental discharge into a morph slash, so my thoughts on how this process happens are as follow: The blade of the weapon itself acts as a switch that allows the energy to flow through the weapon, so when the energy stored in the phials is about to get released, you are able to partially stop this process via removing the blade, maintaining the energy of the phials in the shield itself(its worth remarking that this process only happens when canceling out of an amped elemental discharge, which is arguably the move in which most energy is released, which is why you can store all phials in one go) . What I mean by partially is that this process is not fully perfect, which is why the energy eventually runs out as time passes as opposed of how it remains indefinitely when stored in a phial(when it's not being used, that is) ✳Red/yellow charge.
-energy release via phial attacks: How are we able to release energy from the phials while in axe mode and why doesn't it charge the shield while doing so? As I mentioned, the blade acts as a switch that allows the energy flow trough the weapon, so when you perform a phial attack, what is actually happening is that you are releasing the energy stored in the phials (which is why you must charge the phials first and why you can't perform phial attacks from the energy stored in the blade), which gets released during the impact or during the motion of the attack itself, however, when the energy is released via impact, its released in a more aggressive way, causing a phial blast (or multiple phial blasts depending on the move you are using. So, if that's the case, why doesn't the shield get charged while doing a phial attack? In both instances, the energy is being released from the phials right? Yes that is correct, but there is a key difference between those processes. When you are performing a phial attack, the energy is only released during that attack, which gets back to its retained state on the phials after the attack ends, but when you morph slash from an amped elemental discharge, the energy from the phials is not retained because you removed the blade from the shield before retaining the energy from the blade (think of it as the electricity remaining on a TV when you plug it off instead of turning it off with the remote control), allowing it to flow freely trough the shield.
-blade charge: You might have noticed that the state caused by extracting energy from the monsters into your blade is not the same as the state in which you charge your blade trough the energy in your shield, but why can't I charge up the blade directly and why can't I put energy from the phials back into the blade? The blade itself has two parts, the blade, and the energy storage. The energy storage is the part of the blade in which the energy gets stored and is able to be transported to the phials. There are two main ways that you can alter the flow of the energy inside the weapon with your blade, via release or via retainment, and both ways function in two degrees. When you release energy, you can either transport the energy from the blade to the phials, or let the energy on the phials flow trough the shield, allowing you to do phial attacks and shield charge. When you retain energy, you can either retain part of the energy stored in the shield into your blade, or stop the energy from flowing during a phial attack. The thing is, the process in which the energy moves from the blade to the phials is not regressive, which means that the only way from storing energy back to the blade is from the energy stored in the shield, which is why the blade part gets charged instead of the energy storage part. ✳Blade charge duration.
And that's basically it! Now I will proceed to address the possible issues that might come from this theory: ✳Why are there two grades of shield charge if the process is for both is supposedly the same? This is a problem exclusive to the mhgu iteration of the weapon, in which you would get a less powefull shield charge if you charged the shield in sword mode than if you were to charge it in axe mode(with the exception of the adept guard move). The process in both instances is the same, as it is shown in both the iterations of mhw and mh4u in which you can go from a saed in both axe and sword mode, so I'm going to put this mechanic as just an ingame mechanic with no lore explanation whatsoever.
✳ If the energy from the blade charge comes from the shield, why doesn't the shield charge time get reduced whenever you charge the sword? I'm gonna use the same excuse as before and put that mechanic as just an ingame mechanic that has no lore explanation (yes I know it's really lame but it's the best I can come up with) ✳What the nig nog is going on with hunter arts? Oh god oh fuck, the ambiguity of the process of these arts just kills me since they mess with the actual mechanism of the weapon as opposed to other weapon arts, but I will try to adress them with the best of my ability -Energy blade: during this hunter art, all the energy stored in the phials is maniphested as an energy blade that your character uses to slice the monster. Why is this the only time the phial energy is maniphested as an energy blade? Absolutely no clue. -Healing phials: in this hunter art your character imbues the phials on the weapon with a healing susbtance, which results in a healing splash when you load the phial energy into the shield. This can be explained as your hunter altering the energy of the phials with an unknown healing component, causing them to have that healing splash effect when charged into the shield. -limit breaker: in this art the hunter modifies the weapon temporally so it's able to store more phial energy. I have no clue on how this happens or why is it temporal. -chainsaw art: this one is completely mind boggling, during this art, your hunter uses the shield/axe head to perform a chainsaw-esque attack, storing energy on the blade while doing so. This contradicts a lot of mechanics, since not only it's the only instance in which the sword gathers energy without a sword attack, but it's also the only time in which an axe attack stores energy whatsoever,so yeah, no clue.
And that would be all! Thanks for reading this far and please post on the comment section your opinion or possible doubts about this theory, they are greatly appreciated. Cya around!
Source: Original link
© Post "Theory on the functionality of the charge blade energy mechanism." for game Monster Hunter World.
Top 10 Most Anticipated Video Games of 2020
2020 will have something to satisfy classic and modern gamers alike. To be eligible for the list, the game must be confirmed for 2020, or there should be good reason to expect its release in that year. Therefore, upcoming games with a mere announcement and no discernible release date will not be included.
Top 15 NEW Games of 2020 [FIRST HALF]
2020 has a ton to look forward to...in the video gaming world. Here are fifteen games we're looking forward to in the first half of 2020.